Featured Content

Bre has been doing some great blogging on the science of sports--and specifically the injuries associated with gymnastics--over at Flying High. Check out this post on the effects of caffeine on athletes for an example. Bre's posts are good for a number of reasons--they're an appropriate length, they're well written, feature good, relevant multimedia content, and teach us something about science or medicine in each one. And, her video blog is great! Nice work, Bre.
3:57 PM 3 comments

Engineers Changing the Conversation

As someone who has studied engineers and engineering for a long time now, and also has a scholarly interest in popular culture (films, books, television) I've noticed that engineers in powerful spots--those in the National Academy of Engineering (NAE), or at the National Science Foundation, or elsewhere--are particularly concerned with how they appear to the general public.  Specifically, it is my sense that they are most worried about being invisible, but they're certainly also worried about negative connotations that might adhere to engineers:  that they are mostly white, mostly male, and mostly very technically narrow (nerdy?).

Engineers are also frequently worried about how they stack up against other professionals.  Doctors?  Plenty of television shows, movies, and books about them.  Same with lawyers (though not always positive depictions, right?) and scientists.  But there aren't a lot of engineers visible in the culture.

There's MacGyver, of course:


And, in an article I wrote once in a book about engineering, there are a handful of films that feature--prominently, or not so prominently, engineers and engineering.  The list I came up with is as follows:


Le Voyage dans la Lune (Trip to the Moon, 1902)
The Iron Horse (1924)
Metropolis (1926)
The Story of Alexander Graham Bell (1939)
Young Tom Edison (1940)
Western Union (1941)
The Fountainhead (1949)
No Highway in the Sky (1951)
The Dambusters (1955)
The Spirit of St. Louis (1957)
The Bridge on the River Kwai (1957)
The Time Machine (1960)
Hellfighters (1968)
Colossus:  The Forbin Project (1970)
Tron (1982): [h/t Benito]
War Games (1983)
The Right Stuff (1983)
Emerald Forest (1985)
Pale Rider (1985)
Top Gun (1986)
Fat Man and Little Boy (1989)
Apollo 13 (1995)
October Sky (1998)
Pi (1998)
Space Cowboys (2000)
Spider-Man (2002)
Paycheck (2003)  [h/t:  Benito]
Spider-Man 2 (2004)
Primer (2004)
Spider-Man 3 (2007)
Iron Man (2008) [h/t:  Michelle]

If you know of others, let me know.   In any case, it's not a very long list, compared with how many you could find featuring doctors or lawyers, or even scientists.

I think a lot of the concern over public perceptions of engineering has to do with engineers wanting respect and recognition for the hard and important work they do.  And, in my opinion, engineers are in fact frequently absent in prominent public debates over science and technology, or they are mistaken for scientists, or they are not labelled as engineers.  This may have something to do with how the profession trains itself, or with how it views the public, or with how the public views them.

But public perception also affects things like recruitment and retention.  And many engineers are concerned that the United States won't be able to recruit as many engineers as it needs to remain competitive.  Whether this is true is up for debate, but it's an argument you hear frequently coming from places like the NAE.

Which is why I think the Changing the Conversation (CTC) project, sponsored by the National Science Foundation and prompted by a report issued by the NAE, is so interesting.  It's intended to be a resource for engineers, educators, media professionals, and others interested in clarifying and promoting messages about engineering.

For example, there is a page of sample messages or talking points about engineering.  These messages were tested with sample audiences to test their effectiveness.

So, what do you think?  Will this matter?  How would it be used by communicators, and to what ends?

And why do you think engineers are largely invisible or marginalized in popular culture and in discussions about science and technology?
1:20 PM 4 comments

A Frightening Hook: Bedbugs

I'm something of an NPR junkie.  I have to do a fair amount of driving because my kids go to two different schools, and I'm one of those annoying parents who thinks her kids probably need to know what's going on in the world, so we listen to public radio quite a bit.

On the ride into work this morning, I heard this story on Colorado Matters, Colorado Public Radio's local news show.  The story is about how Denver has one of the largest and most persistent bed bug problems in the country.


I'd heard stories of bed bugs--another one of my favorite radio shows This American Life did a story on them a while back--and I'm interested in them because I'm pretty grossed out by bugs, and am maybe a little OCD, and if we ended up having a bed bug infestation in our house I'd probably consider burning the thing down.

Bed bugs, if you're not familiar, are a little harder to kill than the proverbial post-apocalyptic cockroach.  They can live anywhere in your home, are nearly impossible to get rid of, and they suck your blood while you sleep, then poop that blood on your sheets and wherever else.  They're my idea of horrific.

What does all this have to do with Science Communication?  Well, it occurred to me that the Colorado Matters story on bed bugs was actually a brilliant form of SC.  The show begins with the host Ryan Warner speaking with one of his friends, who had a bed bug infestation (and still has it) and has to live with it.  We hear about his struggles with bed bugs in fairly graphic detail.  It's fascinating and (for me) a gross-out.

But then, the show goes on to interview a specialist in bed bug biology and behavior, Gail Getty.  Getty speaks about the size of the bugs, their behaviors, and what it takes to get rid of them in strikingly clear language.  And it occurred to me, aha!  Here is a scientist who knows how to talk to laypeople.

The show is formatted with a really clever hook, in other words.  A hook (or news peg) is the thing that draws you into the story in the first place, either by making the content relevant to you in some way or by "hooking" or pegging the story on to another big news story.  If the Colorado Matters bed bug story had just started out as a story about entomology (the study of bugs) it might not have been so interesting.  But instead, we start out with the story of a man who is battling the bugs.  The human interest side draws us in, and then all of sudden the science becomes relevant and interesting.

A pretty good trick.
6:21 PM 1 comments

The BP Oil Spill: Possible Research Questions

BP Research Project

Format:  20-minute presentation (engagement encouraged) and follow-up blog post for CommForge

Points:  100

Required elements of presentation:

·      Introduction to research question
o   Why is this question important?
o   What does it help us to learn about the BP oil spill and SC?

·      Justification for constraints of research question (why is bounded the way it is?)

·      Literature review
o   What have others written about your topic or about topics like it?
o   Is your literature scholarly?  If not, can you justify why not?

·     Methodology
o   What data did you look at to answer your question?
o   Why is this the appropriate data to consider given your question?
o   What data is not considered and why?
o   What weaknesses exist in your data collection techniques?  What gaps are there?

·      Findings
o   What are your findings?
o   Are there questions you weren’t able to answer?
o   If you were able to revise your research question now, knowing what you know, how would you do this?

·      Discussion
o   What does your study tell us about science communication generally?
o   Can you make connections to topics we’ve discussed or read about in class?


Format for blog post:

Your blog post will be much less academic than your presentation.  You’ll want to focus on presenting your research question and your findings in a way appropriate for a lay audience.  Your post should be of medium-length and conform to the conventions of blog posting as already discussed in class.


We spent the first half of class tonight generating possible communication-related research questions about the BP oil spill that occurred in the summer of 2010.  Students will spend time preparing presentations and blog posts answering their questions.  Here they are:

Research Questions:  Science Communication and the BP Oil Spill
1.        Looking at commercials produced by BP, how did they frame the spill?
2.       What forms of upstream engagement did BP use, if any?
3.       What was the immediate response of frequent readers of BBC after capping the spill.
4.       How was the local reaction from the Louisiana Newspaper compared to the reaction from the Denver Post, taken from 1 month following the spill?
5.       How do man on the street articles in the New York Times compare with their science communication articles pertaining to the spill?
6.       How did the White House’s framing of the BP spill change over time?
7.       How did the frequency and content of press releases from other oil companies change in the weeks following the oil spill?
8.       How has the model of science communication within BP progressed as a result of the spill?
9.       Following the initial reports of the spill what were the differences in the facts reported by Fox News vs. MSNBC
4:43 PM 1 comments

Blog Self-Interview

Please answer the following questions about you and your blog, on your blog.

What is the purpose of this blog?
Who is the imagined audience(s) of this blog?
Have my posts matched up with my purpose/audience?  What/who might I be overlooking in defining my purpose/audience this way?
What can I do to encourage more reader participation with my blog?
How can I expand my audience in this class?  Outside of this class?
How would I characterize the tone of my blog?
What do I hope to get out of writing this blog?
What would I like others to get out of it?
What are the strengths of my blog/my blogging?
What are the weaknesses?
How would I describe my tone?
Have I used a deficit model in my writing, or something else?  How would I know?
How have I characterized (implicitly or explicitly) science, engineering, and/or technology in my blog? 
How have I characterized myself?
3:12 PM 0 comments

Comments on Reading Quiz 1

Much to my dismay, the outcomes of the first reading quiz suggest some misunderstandings of key concepts in Science Communication, as they were laid out in the last two readings (in Holliman et al). Some of you not only misunderstood the "deficit model," for example, and, worse, then embodied it on your quizzes, writing comments such as "The deficit model means the public is ignorant, and it works because that is the correct way to view the public."

So...let's talk about those questions again. I'm borrowing some answers (posted here anonymously and occasionally aggregated) from those of you who answered the following questions correctly:


1. What might be wrong with the statement, "The more science communication (SC) the better"?

Good possible answer:

"The amount of communication isn't as important as the quality of the communication. Thinking in terms of quantity lends itself to the deficit approach, thinking that the only way people can be involved with science is to have information thrown at them by scientists. This attitude does not foster engagement from the public."

2. What is the deficit approach to science communication (SC) and why does it persist as the dominant model of SC?

Good possible answer:

"The deficit model uses one-way communication with a passive audience such as a lecture with no questions. Scientists have long had the notion that the uneducated public (having knowledge deficits) just need knowledge dumped in their laps, and that they are the ones to do it. It remains dominant because scientists are more devoted to their research than to engaging the public in a meaningful way.  And public engagement is difficult.  But this attitude must change if the deficit model is to ever be removed as the dominant model in SC."

3. What is meant by "upstream engagement"?

Good possible answer:

"Upstream engagement" is an approach to involving the public in a dialogue concerning emerging technologies to get a sense of their opinions and input on the issue or study.  Obvious questions like, 'What are some alternatives to what we have planned?' can be asked that scientists may not have thought about.  This approach was used with GM/nanotechnology as the issues for debate.  The emphasis here is on when engagement happens (before studies or technologies are completed or released), i.e., upstream."

4.  What key challenges or risks do we face when trying to "engage" the public in forms of SC?  In other words, what is hard about public engagement?

Good possible answer:

"Some scientists feel that there should not be a democratic approach to SC because the public doesn't know enough about science.  Scientific research often hinders scientists' efforts to engage the public because it is not funded/rewarded.  Also, the public may take away messages from the effort that are anti-science or based on misconceptions, and scientists may see their projects jeopardized as a result.  Finally, some engagement efforts may be co-opted by special interest groups or others not interested in democratic discussions."

5.  What does it mean to "put the politics back in science?"

Good possible answer:

"To open up the hard questions of science, and how science is done and funded, to the public.  Allow for public debates regarding uncertainties, flows in research, erroneous assumptions, etc.  Bring key scientific issues and processes up for debate--make them transparent.  We must discuss topics such as what science we need, versus what we want, and issues of uncertainty.  Enhancing public involvement in science should be seen as an advantage and not a hindrance."
3:02 PM 4 comments

Using Video in Your Blogs

We've mentioned using multimedia in your blogs pretty much since the first night of class.  But we haven't talked much about guidelines.

Check out this video, distributed by the online newsletter Planet-Profit Report:



It's not terribly hi-tech, right?  Your videos don't have to be either, but note some things this video does well:

1)  It's a manageable length.  Keep in mind that most readers of your blog typically don't plan on spending any more than a few minutes browsing your post and, unless they're really passionate about your topic, probably won't watch a long video.  So keep your videos short, for the most part--3 minutes, max.  And if you post a longer video, indicate to your readers what to pay special attention to (i.e., "Fast forward to 33.14 for Johnson's most interesting point on electric cars."  Don't be afraid to edit things down, or cut out parts that move a little slowly.

2)  It uses intertitles.  Intertitles are those screens in-between interview questions that either quickly pose the question before the interviewee answers it or that split up the video into manageable chunks.  Basically, they're like headings for your video, and they keep things feeling as if they are paced well and moving right along.  Most basic video editing software allows you to place these into your video fairly easily.

3)  It uses cutaway shots.  Cutaway shots are those shots that are edited into the "talking head" part of the interview, so that we're not just watching the interviewee the whole time.  He's talking about gas prices, we're seeing a guy driving an electric car.  Keeps things interesting.

Don't be too intimidated by the terminology or technology, here.  You can shoot a decent, interesting, useful video on your cell phone.  Just keep it short, don't zoom in/out much, hold your camera or phone steady, and then post!
2:48 PM 6 comments

You're Not the Only Ones

While sifting through my emails this week, this story from the Columbia Journalism Review popped up.  It's about a group of high school bloggers who are writing for Scitable, a new site from Nature publishing group featuring student writing of all kinds, but focused primarily on college-age audiences.



Scitable is a form of public engagement, an effort on the part of the publishers of the journal Nature and other publications to reach out and create conversations about science among different sorts of audiences.

Take a minute, visit Scitable, and let me know what you think.  You all (college students) are the supposed audience for the site.  How do you navigate it?  Does it interest you?  Could you imagine doing this sort of writing yourself?  How does your blog compare with the blogs at Scitable?

Most important, what does this sort of "engagement" accomplish?  To paraphrase Sarah Davies, what is the purpose of this kind of Public Engagement in Science and Technology (PEST)?  Is Scitable accomplishing that purpose?